# Efficacy of awake prone positioning in patients with covid-19 related hypoxemic respiratory failure: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials

Weatherald J, Parhar KKS, Al Duhailib Z, et al. BMJ. 2022. PMID [36740866](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36740866/). DOI [10.1136/bmj-2022-071966](https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2022-071966).

## Clinical question (PICO)

| Element | Detail |
| --- | --- |
| Population | Non-intubated adults with hypoxemic respiratory failure due to covid-19 |
| Intervention | Awake prone positioning |
| Comparison | Usual care |
| Outcome | Endotracheal intubation |

## Study design

**Systematic review / meta-analysis**

Meta-analysis

Detected from publication type. Evidence: Meta-Analysis (publication type), Systematic Review (publication type), meta-analysis (abstract keyword).

## Key results

- Reported relative effect: RR 0.83 (95% CI 0.73–0.94)
- CER (assumed control event rate): 29.8%
- EER (experimental event rate): 24.7%
- ARR (absolute risk reduction): 5.1 percentage points (95% CI 1.8 to 8.0)
- RRR (relative risk reduction): 17.0%
- NNT 20 (95% CI 13–56)

Notes on these numbers:

- This absolute effect is estimated from an assumed control event rate of 29.8%, so it only applies to patients whose untreated risk is close to that figure.

## Critical appraisal

Appraised from: Abstract only.

An Unclear verdict means the source above does not settle that question: it records a limit on what the reader could check, not a fault found in the study. Where an item was checked against a different document, that source is shown beside its verdict.

### Internal validity

| # | Item | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Were the question and the eligibility rules set down before the search began, in a protocol or registration that can be checked? | Unclear |
| 2 | Was the search wide enough to find the evidence, covering more than one database and reaching beyond what is easy to retrieve? | Unclear |
| 3 | Did two or more people screen the records and extract the data independently, with a stated way of settling disagreements? | — |
| 4 | Was each included study appraised for how it was conducted, and does that appraisal feed into what the review concludes? | — |
| 5 | Was the scatter between the individual study results examined and explained, rather than only reported as a statistic? | — |
| 6 | Are the studies alike enough in population, intervention and outcome definition for a single combined number to mean anything? | — |
| 7 | Did the review confront the possibility that completed studies were never published, or that the small ones report larger effects than the large ones? | — |
| 8 | Is the confidence the pooled estimate deserves stated, taking in the soundness, the consistency, the precision and the relevance of what went into it? | — |

### Applicability

Applicability is not internal validity. A trial can be conducted impeccably and still not transfer to the patient in front of you, and a trial with real methodological weaknesses can still be about exactly your patient. Nothing below is a verdict on how the study was run.

| # | Item | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 9 | Do the populations, interventions and comparators inside the review match the patients and the usual care you are deciding about? | — |

### Funding & conflicts

Recorded as fact, never scored. Industry funding is not by itself a source of bias, and a field left blank means nothing was recorded here — not that there was nothing to record.

- Funder: Not recorded.
- Sponsor or funder role: Not recorded.
- Author conflicts declared: Not recorded.
- Where this came from: Not recorded.

### Notes on flagged items

Items answered No — judgements the reader made, about the study or about its fit:

- None.

Items answered Unclear — the source used does not settle these, which is not a finding against the study:

- Item 1: PROSPERO CRD42022314856 is named. Check that it was registered before the last search, 4 March 2022. Usually needs the protocol, the statistical analysis plan or the trial registry.
- Item 2: Three databases are named. Trial registries and unpublished data are not mentioned: check the methods. Usually needs the full text — an abstract rarely has this detail.

## Bottom line

Pooled trials show fewer intubations with awake prone positioning, and no clear effect on mortality. How the trials differed in setting and adherence needs the full text.

## Discussion questions

1.
2.
3.

Generated with Journal Club Helper for educational purposes. Verify against the full text.
