Example one-page summary
This is a one-page summary exported from Journal Club Helper, unedited, for a published meta-analysis in The BMJ. For this example a person did what a reader would: typed the PICO, chose which of the abstract's ratios to use and entered the baseline risk to apply it to, marked two checklist questions Unclear with a note on each, and wrote the bottom line. The rest is what the extension filled in or calculated, or left blank for the reader.
The absolute figures are calculated from the relative risk and that baseline risk, so they differ a little from the crude rates the abstract reports. The bottom line only shows what a reader might write. It is not a clinical conclusion and not advice.
The exported Markdown file is available as well.
Efficacy of awake prone positioning in patients with covid-19 related hypoxemic respiratory failure: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials
Weatherald J, Parhar KKS, Al Duhailib Z, et al. BMJ. 2022. PMID 36740866. DOI 10.1136/bmj-2022-071966.
Clinical question (PICO)
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Population | Non-intubated adults with hypoxemic respiratory failure due to covid-19 |
| Intervention | Awake prone positioning |
| Comparison | Usual care |
| Outcome | Endotracheal intubation |
Study design
Systematic review / meta-analysis
Meta-analysis
Detected from publication type. Evidence: Meta-Analysis (publication type), Systematic Review (publication type), meta-analysis (abstract keyword).
Key results
- Reported relative effect: RR 0.83 (95% CI 0.73–0.94)
- CER (assumed control event rate): 29.8%
- EER (experimental event rate): 24.7%
- ARR (absolute risk reduction): 5.1 percentage points (95% CI 1.8 to 8.0)
- RRR (relative risk reduction): 17.0%
- NNT 20 (95% CI 13–56)
Notes on these numbers:
- This absolute effect is estimated from an assumed control event rate of 29.8%, so it only applies to patients whose untreated risk is close to that figure.
Critical appraisal
Appraised from: Abstract only.
An Unclear verdict means the source above does not settle that question: it records a limit on what the reader could check, not a fault found in the study. Where an item was checked against a different document, that source is shown beside its verdict.
Internal validity
| # | Item | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Were the question and the eligibility rules set down before the search began, in a protocol or registration that can be checked? | Unclear |
| 2 | Was the search wide enough to find the evidence, covering more than one database and reaching beyond what is easy to retrieve? | Unclear |
| 3 | Did two or more people screen the records and extract the data independently, with a stated way of settling disagreements? | — |
| 4 | Was each included study appraised for how it was conducted, and does that appraisal feed into what the review concludes? | — |
| 5 | Was the scatter between the individual study results examined and explained, rather than only reported as a statistic? | — |
| 6 | Are the studies alike enough in population, intervention and outcome definition for a single combined number to mean anything? | — |
| 7 | Did the review confront the possibility that completed studies were never published, or that the small ones report larger effects than the large ones? | — |
| 8 | Is the confidence the pooled estimate deserves stated, taking in the soundness, the consistency, the precision and the relevance of what went into it? | — |
Applicability
Applicability is not internal validity. A trial can be conducted impeccably and still not transfer to the patient in front of you, and a trial with real methodological weaknesses can still be about exactly your patient. Nothing below is a verdict on how the study was run.
| # | Item | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 9 | Do the populations, interventions and comparators inside the review match the patients and the usual care you are deciding about? | — |
Funding & conflicts
Recorded as fact, never scored. Industry funding is not by itself a source of bias, and a field left blank means nothing was recorded here — not that there was nothing to record.
- Funder: Not recorded.
- Sponsor or funder role: Not recorded.
- Author conflicts declared: Not recorded.
- Where this came from: Not recorded.
Notes on flagged items
Items answered No — judgements the reader made, about the study or about its fit:
- None.
Items answered Unclear — the source used does not settle these, which is not a finding against the study:
- Item 1: PROSPERO CRD42022314856 is named. Check that it was registered before the last search, 4 March 2022. Usually needs the protocol, the statistical analysis plan or the trial registry.
- Item 2: Three databases are named. Trial registries and unpublished data are not mentioned: check the methods. Usually needs the full text — an abstract rarely has this detail.
Bottom line
Pooled trials show fewer intubations with awake prone positioning, and no clear effect on mortality. How the trials differed in setting and adherence needs the full text.
Discussion questions
Generated with Journal Club Helper for educational purposes. Verify against the full text.